Q & A on Recessed Can Lights

Q.

Hi - I came across your site in trying to find answers about LED recessed lighting and thought I would take the chance and email you, I hope that is OK. (Before wasting your time, I am in New York, and understand that you are in SF, so I'll be blunt - I doubt that you will be making money by answering these questions! I will understand if you do not answer. :-)

I have questions to do with a residential remodel project and thought I would come to the experts - you - rather than relying on all of the conflicting answers I have had from local lighting stores & designers!

I am looking at installing remodel recessed lighting throughout the house and would like to be energy efficient - and use LED not CFL.

it seems there are three solutions...(at least 3 different people have told me three different things...)

(1) use low voltage cans - (approx $50) each with LED bulbs (approx $30 each) - total $80 per unit

(2) use regular cans (approx $40 each) with retrofit LED modules (approx $90 each) - total $130 per unit

(3) use dedicated remodel LED cans with integral bulb - approx $230 each

What is your advice please - I'd hate to spend $80 * 40 ($3200) units and have a bad solution, equally I'd hate to spend $230 * 40 units ($9,200) if there is a cheaper option!
Regards,

Mick

A.

Hi Mick,

You don't specify brands here so I can only speak in generalities.
If I were you (and not knowing anything about code requirements there), I would choose option 2.

My reason is this: Installing regular cans will give you more options down the road.
For instance: You might want to try the new Vu1 R30 lamps instead of LEDs.

There will be a number of new products coming out in the near future that I can not even imagine. Most will be designed to directly replace incandescent 65 watt lamps. If you can stick with that kind of fixture you will more likely be able to try them all.

You can always send me a check if you think my advice is worthwhile Mick. Good work is good work, no matter where it is performed. :-)

NOTE: Here in California we must use GU-24 base sockets, and lamps with a special base to fit them, in remodels and new construction (Existing screw-in base fixtures are grandfathered). CA Title 24 mandates occupancy sensors and/or dimmers and/or high-efficacy lights. I don't think you're there yet in New York.

Peggy